691 8:34

National Pie Judge Spreads Gospel of Sugar, Butter, and Flour

This lifelong baker was afraid of pies - when she overcomes her hesitancy, she undertakes a baking adventure that leads to hundreds of satisfied customers.

8:34

Subscribe Now For A Free Five Step Tutorial

Get a free five-part email course that shows you how to find, validate, and launch your side hustle idea — no experience required.

What It's About

The pie is cast: get ready for a ful-filling helping of sugar, butter, and flour.

Business Model
Product
Skills Required
Baking & Marketing
Complexity
Low
Profit Potential
Medium

Words of Wisdom

Catherine's story is a good example that even if a side hustle might sound "as easy as pie," there are still a lot of challenges — even if you're a national pie judge.

Fun Fact

According to the American Pie Council, Americans buy more than 186 million pies at the grocery store each year. That is enough to stretch around the globe and beyond. 7% of American have also tried to pass off store bought pie as homemade.

Notes from Chris

Episode 691
Catherine earns her living as a journalist, but spends a lot of her off-the-clock hours finding excuses to bake. As if anyone needs an excuse!

A longtime baker, for many years Catherine was intimidated by pies. There was just so much that could go wrong—even though beauty is in the Pie of the beholder, you could still do something as simple as overworking the dough and end up with an absolute disaster.

It wasn’t until her 11-year-old daughter challenged her. Her daughter had been turning out delicious pies at her dad’s house, and Catherine decided she needed to raise her game.

She began CurvyMama’s Pies just as a blog, chronicling an apprenticeship she did at Bubby’s, a master pie bakers in New York City. There was just one problem.

You could read nice words and stories about pies, and Catherine wrote a lot of them … but research shows that pies are best appreciated as a more sensory experience. When she got back to the newsroom where she worked as a journalist, her colleagues asked, how can I get some of this goodness?

So she started offering pies for sale, especially around Thanksgiving. She settled on a price of $24 per pie, and put up a list for her friends and family to order from on her blog.

And that was when she learned a big lesson. Instead of giving people an option of four different flavors like any sane person would do, she let people order whatever they wanted. When you’re going to bake at scale, you can’t let everyone order whatever they want. If you have to turn out 15 pies, you should offer a limited selection so that you can bake in larger batches.

For the next several years, Catherine continued her pie hustle, peaking at an annual record of 122 pies in 2014. Not surprisingly, Thanksgiving was the busiest season, comprising up to 50% of her yearly orders.

Catherine also began teaching pie workshops, where aspiring bakers would learn from her hard-earned skills. She traveled the country, meeting pie makers near and far. And yes, she even became a judge at the Iowa state fair.

Catherine has recently relocated to the Los Angeles area. She’s now taking a break while she looks for a space to teach more workshops.

It’s been a sweet and filling adventure … no matter which way you slice it.

 

 

MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE:
  • Curvy Mama Pies: Learn more and order your own pie at Catherine's website!
 

SEE ALSO: Inspiration is good; inspiration combined with action is better. Now get back to work!

Yours in the revolution,

cg-sig-newsletter
Quote of the Day
"I’m thoroughly in love with pie. When I’m making the morning coffee, I’m counting the hours until I can get my hands back into dough."
—Catherine Gewertz #SideHustleSchool
Read the full transcript

This transcript was generated from the episode audio and may contain minor errors.

[Music]

What's up, what's up my friends? Today's story, you're gonna like this one. This is Side Hustle School, by the way. And today's story is dog stocking hustle earns husky payoff. It turns out that there is a lot of money in Christmas stockings for dogs.

Now for everybody out there who wants to be a life coach and is wondering why nobody wants to pay them, you need to take all those motivational quotes off your Instagram and start putting up pictures of golden retrievers in the snow. The agency employee that you'll hear about in this story never saw himself starting a side hustle. He was perfectly happy working for that agency, his company. But when he noticed one of his marketing clients making bank on seasonal pet gifts, he just couldn't roll over anymore. He had to sit, he had to fetch.

Well, mostly he had to act and put together this dog Christmas stocking hustle. I'll tell you how it came to be and something important he learned along the way, a good lesson that could be helpful to somebody out there as well, right after the break. [Music]

Jeff Moriarty has been in marketing for 17 years. He's not stuck in the old ways of doing things. Over those years, he's adapted to become a master of search engine optimization, or SEO, and has a knack for pay-per-click advertising.

These two skills led him into the seasonal business that would become his new side hustle. One of Jeff's clients at the agency sold dog supplies, leashes, food bowls, that kind of thing. But you never would have guessed, you probably never would have guessed, the top seller. That top seller was dog Christmas stockings. That's right, stockings outsold everything else and by a wide margin.

Jeff was the only person in the company working with this client, and his SEO strategy was working. The company was getting more and more traffic, but the owner just wasn't into it. Over the years, it had become harder and harder to compete with Amazon, and his margins were already slim, so he decided to exit the business and close his e-commerce store. This was in 2014, and Jeff felt like he had a secret. None of his coworkers knew how well the store had been doing from those stockings.

Should he go for his own dog Christmas stocking business? He didn't really see himself as a side hustler. He liked the marketing agency life, and it seemed like adding another responsibility on top of that would just be too much. But then he couldn't stop thinking about it. Weeks and months went by.

Every now and then, he'd look at the search rankings to see if any other stores were dominating the Google rankings using his strategy, and whenever he looked, he was unimpressed. Sure, there were some other stores selling dog Christmas stockings, but none of them seemed to have a dedicated, mindful strategy. Maybe they just kept getting distracted by squirrels, or maybe they just didn't know how to execute, but Jeff did. The trick that worked for his former client wasn't trying to rank for broad phrases like dog Christmas stockings. The trick was targeting very specific phrases like Basset Hound Christmas stockings.

And while no more than a few hundred people were searching these breed-specific phrases each Christmas season, he knew that once he had a couple dozen breed options up, he'd be able to bring in a significant amount of traffic. Now these people were also willing buyers. So finally, a full year after his client closed up shop, Jeff gave in. The opportunity was just too good. The strategy, too obvious.

But he didn't have a lot of money to invest, and he didn't want to end up with tons of product in his garage. So he decided to go with a business model he'd been hearing a lot about for the past few years. That model was drop shipping. Rather than buying lots of product, all those dog stockings, and shipping them out himself, he would partner with a supplier who would also act as his company's fulfillment center when orders came in. After some searching, he found a partner and ordered a few dozen samples.

He also built a bare-bones Shopify website. With less than $1,000 spent, he was ready for business. In his store, dogchristmastockings.com launched in the fall of 2015. It was finally time to execute that strategy he'd been brooding over for the past year. And he had to do it quickly because the prime stocking buying season was just a couple months out.

Jeff focused in on the individual product pages. They would rank for those breed-specific keywords. He would add the keywords in the URL, he'd add them on multiple subheadings across the page, and then several times throughout the text itself. It wasn't anything fancy, but dogstockings were not a competitive industry, so it was enough to beat the dozens of other sites that didn't seem to be trying very hard. 42 product pages, and a couple weeks later, organic traffic began trickling in.

It was slow at first, but as Jeff checked his rankings daily, he became more and more excited. That November, dogchristmastockings.com made its first sale, and its second, and its 10th. By Christmas, Jeff had sold over $1,000 worth of product. Now, after the dropshipping fees, his profit was just a small portion of that, but it was enough for the work he put into it, and he knew he could do better next year. So he took a few weeks the next year to write new product descriptions, refine the feel of the website, and add a few additional products.

And it worked. The 2016 season saw nearly 10x the growth. Of course, not everything he tried ended up working out. For example, one weekend, he spent about 15 hours adding every product to eBay, only to make a single sale on that platform. It was rough.

But despite those missteps, traffic was still up. Over the 2017 season, Jeff sold over $20,000 worth of product, fetching himself a nice profit. So as we roll over into the holidays this year, he is pumped to see how 2018 turns out. His pages are ranking higher than ever, crushing the competition with three years of solid history, and he's got even more extra products he's trying out. It turned out to be a great seasonal project, and he likes it that way.

He gets to brainstorm fun ways to grow throughout the year, spend a few months hustling for those basset hound orders, gets plenty of time to rest, and then the cycle repeats. So let's sing the praises of a seasonal business. This story reminds me of "Letters from Santa," which was episode 338, actually called Santa's Letter Writing Gig, hustles down the chimney. In that story, a woman earns $5,000 each holiday season writing personalized letters from Santa. Now, the funny thing is nobody wants to hear from Santa during 11 months of the year, so she ramps up her letter writing sleigh in November and then goes back to her regular life in January.

So these kinds of projects can be a really good fit, at least for a lot of people. And in fact, Jeff said, I would personally like more seasonal businesses. I love the practice of working hard for a couple of months, then taking it easy, working hard, then taking it easy. It's honestly not difficult. I work on increasing the positioning year round, and then when the holidays hit, I get to see the fruits of my labor.

So as I said, seasonal businesses could be a good fit for some people. Now, last but not least, as funny as it is, there is a powerful lesson in focusing on search results and really targeting results like Basset Hound Christmas stockings. Because even though there aren't a ton of people searching for a phrase like that, a lot of those people are ready to buy. So there's low competition, and the people who are searching, you don't search for a Basset Hound Christmas stocking, unless you're fairly serious about buying. So consider how you might apply this to whatever it is that you sell or you hope to sell.

Definitely a good lesson there. We'll talk about that some more in some future episodes. There's a lot you can learn. Okay, friends, I hope you liked it. I hope you have a good day today, wherever you are in the world.

Inspiration is also good, but inspiration with action is better. I hope you listen, I hope you take action, I hope you do something for yourself. Today's Barking Show notes are at sidehustleschool.com/691. That is for episode 691. Be back again with you tomorrow, 692, coming up.

Once again, my name is Chris Guillebeau. Go fetch yourself a profit. This is Side Hustle School. [Music]

Find your side hustle

Search 450 real case studies by income, difficulty, and business model. The Side Hustle Finder helps you skip the browsing and find ideas that actually match your situation.

Explore the Finder →
Side Hustle book
From the Host

Side Hustle: From Idea to Income in 27 Days

The step-by-step guide behind many of the stories on this show. Find your idea, validate it, and start earning — no experience required.

See all books →

Keep in Touch

Chris Guillebeau speaking to a packed crowd

There's a new story every single day on Side Hustle School. Episodes are produced to be short and to the point — I know you're busy. Be sure you subscribe to get a weekly recap of each episode!

Email hello@chrisguillebeau.com
Say Hi From your favorite airport

To infinity and beyond,
Chris Guillebeau